Day-after-day on the Higher East Facet, traces snake outdoors the neighborhood’s two Butterfield Markets. These crowds are notably putting due to the variety of age on show: There are previous folks. There are infants. There are {couples}, nannies, vacationers, mates, and medical professionals. At 3 p.m. on a latest Wednesday, a pair of crop-topped grad college students transplanted from California stood forward of a taut, impatient middle-aged Australian in athleisure. “We don’t want the queue to be any longer than it’s!” she interjected, nudging everybody alongside. Everybody, regardless of the age, waits for a similar factor: Butterfield Market’s home frozen yogurt, swirled into robin’s-egg-blue cups and, inevitably, posted to Instagram. “I feel it’s fairly definitely worth the hype,” stated the extra yogurt savvy of the Californians.
She most popular it to the fro-yo from Madison Fare, three blocks uptown, the place earlier that day a quintet of contoured Chicagoans had been consuming frozen Greek yogurt bathed in Dubai-chocolate–impressed pistachio sauce. “We simply noticed it on TikTok!” stated a 22-year-old named Amy. Fro-yo had been on their trip itinerary: Central Park, Broadway, Madison Fare. Frozen yogurt, typically, was “positively getting standard once more,” she added, pushed by a mixture of nostalgia and the truth that “entry to social media creates a approach for folks to market their random companies and stuff.”
Influencers and would-be influencers alike are perpetually posting about one yogurt or the opposite: This fro-yo is 10/10, so value it, it’s oh my God the perfect yogurt they’ve ever had. Madison Fare added its yogurt final summer season. Chef Amin Kinana had wished to drum up enterprise when his regulars fled town for the Hamptons. The response was rapid and overwhelming: “I didn’t get it, to be sincere. I used to be like, Okay, no matter, that is gonna die out quickly, but it surely didn’t. It simply retains going and going,” he stated. “This factor with yogurt is rising very massive.”
It will be doable to put in writing this off as an Higher East Facet phenomenon, a tiny Frozen Yogurt Triangle, besides it is a metropolis that’s vulnerable to fro-yo booms, and in speaking to dozens of followers over the previous few weeks, it has turn into clear that one thing larger actually is occurring in regard to this factor with yogurt.
Fro-yo at Madison Fare.
Photograph: Heami Lee
I attempted to get in contact with somebody from Pinkberry, onetime icon of the big-city fro-yo scene, to ask whether or not it deliberate to capitalize on the fro-yo frenzy, however no one at its company headquarters in Arizona referred to as me again (notably, its mother or father firm, Kahala Manufacturers, additionally runs the final two Tasti D-Lites in New York). As a substitute, I walked over to the Pinkberry retailer in Park Slope to speak to an worker. She has been with the corporate for 11 years. Nothing a lot has modified, she advised me (“besides the costs!”). It was nonetheless busy, particularly proper after college. I requested her what the preferred taste was as of late, and she or he advised me all of them.
Pinkberry could also be resting on its laurels, however certainly one of its longtime rivals isn’t. 16 Handles is the non secular reverse of the artisanal Madison Fare or the Erewhon-like Butterfield, but it, too, is making a play to recapture the eye of this metropolis and lots of different cities as properly. Neil Hershman, the chain’s 30-year-old CEO, took over in 2022, with YouTube star Danny Duncan — whose merch line contains “Virginity Rocks” T-shirts and “MILF Patrol” hoodies — as chief artistic officer. Collectively, they launched what they intend to be a frozen-yogurt renaissance. Hershman, who has a vested curiosity in saying so, is emphatic that we as a tradition are on the precipice of a brand new yogurt second. “Our model has simply been on a tear these previous few years, up and up and up,” he stated, citing “three straight years of over 10 p.c income progress.” Loads of that’s in suburban areas — 16 Handles is opening new shops in Texas, South Carolina, Florida, and Arizona — however Hershman has his eye on Brooklyn (“A progress marketplace for us proper now”); “the forgotten borough, Staten Island” (his phrases); and, in fact, Manhattan, though he “can’t disclose precisely the place and when.”
If Hershman means downtown, he shall be competing with Tradition, which has been open for a decade however is the place “each West Village Lady” is at the moment on line, in keeping with Mélisse Martineau, who’s 25 and works in style. “We’ll textual content and be like, ‘Tradition?’ You will get out of the home, go for a little bit stroll, meet up,” she stated. “You don’t need to spend $20 and get drunk. It’s simply very healthful.”
Butterfield Market can be increasing fro-yo’s attain past uptown: This summer season, a location is opening in Lengthy Island Metropolis with — for the primary time — self-serve fro-yo. “That’s form of massive information,” stated Joelle Obsatz, a third-generation proprietor (alongside along with her brother) and the top of selling. “I don’t understand how Instagrammable it’ll be in comparison with our served fro-yo, however I feel folks shall be completely satisfied.” She added, ”There’s some nostalgia to fro-yo.”
Nostalgia for what? In contrast to ice cream, which evokes childhood, fro-yo evokes eras, typically one which spans from 2006 (the opening of Manhattan’s first Pinkberry, on West thirty second Road) to roughly 2014, a stretch of years outlined by Women, Fleet Foxes, The E-book of Mormon, and diced strawberries or sugary cereal spooned atop tart swirls of low-fat green-tea yogurt. Fro-yo retailers had “colonized your entire island of Manhattan and claimed massive chunks of the boroughs,” lamented The Observer in 2012, itemizing them: “Yogurtland, Yogurt Station, Yorganic, Loopy Bananas, Off the Wall, Yogurt Tradition, Strawberry Fields, Yogorino, Victory Backyard, Forty Carrots, Village Yogurt, Phileo Yogurt, Berrywild, Lorax Frozen Yogurt, The Lite Selection, Chill Berry, Yogurt Metropolis, YoGo Yogurt Truck, and Yogo Swirl,” and that wasn’t even counting the “indefatigable nationwide chains.”
“We received’t be stunned once we see a sickening 7-Eleven slithering into this spot, or a frozen-yogurt banality,” Jeremiah Moss wrote in Jeremiah’s Vanishing New York, mourning the 2013 closure of the Rawhide, a historic leather-based bar in Chelsea. For years, frozen yogurt was particular, after which it was a blight, after which everybody moved on to inexperienced juice.
One issue driving fro-yo’s return: This can be very Instagrammable.
Photograph: Heami Lee
One fro-yo evangelist ready for the resurgence is Maya Kosoff, who’s 32 and moved to New York in 2014. On the time, Crimson Mangos and Pinkberries have been everywhere in the metropolis, however their numbers quickly dwindled. 4 years in the past, Kosoff began texting the group chat: What had occurred to all of them? “We have been like, ‘On a sizzling summer season day generally, what would actually do the trick is a small bowl of authentic tart frozen yogurt with some strawberries and mochi topping.’” Everybody on the group chat agreed that’s precisely what they wished, however the place might they discover it? “There have been principally no fro-yo locations left,” Kosoff stated. “I feel it’s nostalgia for, like, a second in time within the 2010s. I don’t know why individuals are nostalgic for that. I don’t even know why I’m nostalgic for it.” I questioned if what she may be nostalgic for was not yogurt however youth.
Almost everybody I spoke to, no matter their NYC arrival date, advised me that frozen yogurt is nostalgic, together with Connor Nix, a regional director for Bloomingdale’s, which is house to Forty Carrots, a yogurt pioneer. Bloomingdale’s credit itself for introducing New York to what was within the early ’70s referred to as “frogurt” and has been extruding it, steadily, elegantly, ever since. Individuals (principally ladies) had been taken by their dad and mom (principally moms) or their grandparents, and now, Nix tells me, they’re “bringing the subsequent technology” — principally daughters — “to it.” The fro-yo wave of the mid-aughts was itself a throwback to the craze of the ’80s and early ’90s, when frozen yogurt emerged as a low-fat, low-calorie various to ice cream. “Consuming ice cream has a stigma now, like smoking,” a New Jersey girl named Alison Weiss advised the New York Instances in 1991. “If somebody comes into the shop whereas I’m ready for my frozen yogurt and asks for ice cream, I stare at them. There’s a complete guilt factor about ice cream.” Frozen yogurt, nevertheless, exuded an “aura of well being,” she stated, regardless that, because the article defined, frozen yogurt isn’t really wholesome by most traditional metrics, and the energy per ounce are by no means fairly as little as one may need.
“It’s not a salad, it’s nonetheless dessert. It’s nonetheless acquired milk fats and cream, it’s nonetheless acquired sugar in it,” conceded Hershman, the 16 Handles CEO. “However what when you might have much less of all these issues?”
That is the timeless attraction of yogurt. It’s indulgence with out punishment, goodness with out struggling. “I feel my love of frozen yogurt got here from a need to have one thing plentiful and that may be all mine on this world however that received’t harm me,” stated the creator and poet Melissa Broder. I had referred to as her as a result of frozen yogurt elements closely in her second novel, Milk Fed, the place it each suppresses and awakens appetites, which suggests she understands the promise of fro-yo in a non secular sense. “Frozen yogurt,” she continued, “is among the closest issues we get to heaven.” I used to be by no means fairly capable of unlock what everybody was actually searching for once they lined up for some frozen yogurt, however Broder in all probability acquired closest to discovering it: “It’s this eager for the infinite and the everlasting, however with out consequence — kind of like the will for God.”
Photograph: Heami Lee
Thanks for subscribing and supporting our journalism.
If you happen to want to learn in print, you too can discover this text within the June 2, 2025, situation of
New York Journal.
Need extra tales like this one? Subscribe now
to help our journalism and get limitless entry to our protection.
If you happen to want to learn in print, you too can discover this text within the June 2, 2025, situation of
New York Journal.