Erik and Lyle Menendez had been denied parole by a California board this week after many years in jail for killing their dad and mom in 1989 at their Beverly Hills mansion.
Throughout two days of hearings, the brothers had been every questioned by panels of two commissioners and requested to talk with full candor on the abuse they suffered in childhood, their mindsets main as much as and after the murders and numerous jail transgressions.
The brothers had been sentenced to life in jail in 1996 for fatally taking pictures Jose and Kitty Menendez. The case has lengthy captivated true crime lovers, with the brothers amassing public help up to now yr after exhibits on Netflix renewed curiosity.
The hearings marked the closest they’ve come to freedom since their convictions. Regardless of every receiving three-year denials, they are going to be eligible to request an administrative evaluate in a single yr. If granted, they may seem earlier than the parole board once more as early as 18 months from now.
Listed below are takeaways from the hearings:
Having prohibited cell telephones isn’t a minor jail infraction
Whereas it won’t look like an enormous deal to the nonincarcerated public, commissioners emphasised to the brothers that their use of illicit cell telephones forged a shadow on their optimistic achievements whereas behind bars.
Cell telephones can be utilized to order hits, transfer medicine in jail and coordinate assaults on officers, they famous. Their presence meant a correctional officer needed to smuggle them in, and a jail gang might have benefited by charging a tax on it, commissioner Robert Barton advised Erik Menendez.
“What I received when it comes to the cellphone and my reference to the skin world was far better than the results of me getting caught with the cellphone,” Erik Menendez mentioned. He mentioned he used it to talk together with his spouse, watch YouTube, hearken to music and watch pornography.
Erik Menendez’s spouse, Tammi Menendez, heart, leaves the Van Nuys West Courthouse after a standing listening to on the homicide conviction of Lyle and Erik Menendez on November 25, 2024. – Robyn Beck/AFP/Getty Photos
In denying him parole, Barton mentioned his habits was “egocentric,” an indication he believes the foundations don’t apply to him and the “ends justify the means.”
Lyle Menendez additionally had two current cellphone infractions, together with one in March.
He mentioned correctional staffers had been monitoring his communications together with his spouse and household and promoting their content material to tabloids, so he noticed cell telephones as a privateness measure.
There was “lots of stress” in his marriage across the time he transferred to the jail in San Diego, and he wished to remain in contact together with his spouse, he mentioned.
“I had satisfied myself that this wasn’t a implies that was harming anybody however myself in a rule violation,” Lyle Menendez mentioned. “I didn’t assume it actually disrupted jail administration very a lot.”
They haven’t been mannequin prisoners as some believed
Of the 2, Erik Menendez dedicated extra severe guidelines infractions.
Commissioners questioned why he related himself with a jail gang known as the Two Fivers and helped them with a tax scheme round 2013.
Menendez mentioned he was attempting to outlive an “extraordinarily violent yard” the place shut associates had been stabbed or raped.
“I used to be in super worry,” he mentioned. “When the Two Fivers got here and requested for assist, I believed this was an amazing alternative to align myself with them and to outlive.”
Menendez advised commissioners that he prioritized defending himself over the foundations as a result of on the time, he had no hope of ever getting out.
He used medicine and alcohol in his early years behind bars however grew to become sober in 2013 on his mom’s birthday, he mentioned.
Whereas Lyle Menendez dedicated fewer violations, commissioner Julie Garland mentioned he nonetheless demonstrated “delinquent character traits like deception, minimization and rule breaking that lie beneath that optimistic floor.”
Prisoners who break guidelines are extra probably to take action in society as properly, she mentioned.
Why they killed their mom stays a sticking level
Commissioners expressed issues over the killing of Kitty Menendez, with Barton saying he discovered that it confirmed Erik Menendez was “devoid of human compassion” on the time.
“I can’t put myself in your house. I don’t know that I’ve ever had rage to that degree, ever,” Barton mentioned. “However that’s nonetheless regarding, particularly because it appears she was additionally a sufferer herself of the home violence.”
Snow covers the gravesite of Jose and Kitty Menendez January 10, 1994, in Princeton, New Jersey. – Yvonne Hemsey/Getty Photos
Barton mentioned the brothers weren’t in imminent worry for his or her lives and may have sought assist from different relations or gone to the police.
As for Lyle Menendez, Garland mentioned taking pictures Kitty Menendez one remaining time was extraordinarily “callous.” She additionally highlighted his actions in protecting up the crime, resembling mendacity to the police and attempting to keep away from prosecution.
Parole denials usually are not unheard-of for prisoners with ‘reasonable danger’
Gov. Gavin Newsom beforehand ordered the California parole board to conduct a danger evaluation of the brothers in response to a clemency request.
Whereas it was by no means made public, Los Angeles County District Lawyer Nathan Hochman revealed in Might that each brothers had been deemed “reasonable danger.”
Barton mentioned he deemed that evaluation to be impartial, so far as he thought of it in any respect.
A 2022 evaluation by the Jail Coverage Initiative confirmed that California prisoners with “reasonable danger” had been granted parole 22% of the time. The nonprofit ranked the state as among the many most troublesome for acquiring parole.
Members of the family again the brothers
Greater than a dozen family members spoke on the two hearings to advocate for his or her launch.
Aunt Teresita Baralt, Jose Menendez’s sister, mentioned she is dying from Stage 4 most cancers and needs to welcome them dwelling.
Teresita Baralt, sister of Jose Menendez, walks on the day that members of Jose and Kitty Menendez’s household meet with District Lawyer Nathan Hochman to press for the resentencing of Erik and Lyle Menendez’s first-degree homicide convictions, in Los Angeles in January. – David Swanson/Reuters
“I need to clarify that though I like my brother, I’ve totally forgiven Erik,” she mentioned. “Erik carries himself with kindness, integrity and energy that comes from persistence and style.”
Natascha Leonardo, Kitty Menendez’s great-niece, promised the parole board that she would offer a house of “unconditional love and stability” for him in Colorado, the place he may spend time with household and nature.
Members of the family mentioned in a press release that whereas they’re upset parole was denied, they don’t seem to be discouraged.
“We all know they’re good males who’ve achieved the work to rehabilitate and are remorseful,” they mentioned. “We love them unconditionally and can proceed to face by them on the journey forward.”
For extra CNN information and newsletters create an account at CNN.com