A Howard College professor tore into the victim-impact assertion delivered by the daddy of slain Texas teen Austin Metcalf, arguing that the teenager’s loss of life “didn’t start with the knife” wielded by Karmelo Anthony however as a substitute that his father’s parenting model was to be blamed as nicely.
Dr. Stacey Patton, a professor at Howard College’s College of Communications, penned an opinion piece titled “Expensive Jeff Metcalf: Your Son Is Lifeless As a result of You Didn’t Train Him That Black Boys Have Boundaries” to Substack on Wednesday on Substack, the place she insinuated Anthony was performing out of self-defense.
“YOU failed to show your boy that Black kids have boundaries,” Patton wrote. “YOU failed educate humility, restraint, or the sacred indisputable fact that one other individual’s physique is just not your jurisdiction. YOU failed to show him that one other youngster’s area is just not a problem to be conquered. YOU failed to show him that “group” doesn’t imply white boys get to resolve who belongs and who doesn’t.”
Patton’s piece was printed a day after Anthony was sentenced to 35 years in jail for the homicide of Metcalf. The case drew nationwide after now 19-year-old Anthony stabbed 17-year-old Metcalf within the coronary heart throughout a confrontation at a highschool monitor assembly in April 2025. The case has turn into a flashpoint in broader debates about race, with Anthony’s supporters arguing he has been handled in another way as a result of he’s Black, whereas critics have rejected efforts to make the homicide of Metcalf, a white teenager, about race.
Grieving Texas Father Speaks Out After Son Was Stabbed To Demise At Excessive College Observe Meet
“YOU clearly failed to show your son that touching, confronting, crowding, testing, or policing one other individual can have penalties,” Patton wrote. “And YOU failed to show him that the identical world that cheers white boys for being daring and aggressive won’t all the time be there to save lots of them once they mistake any individual else’s restraint for permission.”
Learn On The Fox Information App
She blasted Jeff for saying that Anthony had failed his mother and father in his choice to homicide his son.
“It’s simpler to face in a courtroom and name Karmelo Anthony a failure than it’s to confess that Austin’s loss of life didn’t start with the knife,” Patton wrote. “It started with each lesson that instructed your son that he had the precise to strategy, problem, and cross a boundary. It started with each grownup who smiled at white boy entitlement and known as it management. It started with each cultural script that taught him Black boys are those to be feared, however by no means taught him that Black boys may also be afraid.
America Nonetheless Cannot Put Down The Race Card. And It is The Disgrace Of Our Nation
Jeff Metcalf speaks in regards to the stabbing loss of life of his son, Austin Metcalf, at a highschool monitor meet.
(Fox Information)
She additionally alleged that Jeff’s victim-impact assertion was rooted in racism, homing in on Jeff saying that Anthony does “not belong” locally due to what he did.
“You don’t belong on this group” is not only a father’s grief spilling over,” Patton wrote. “It’s a declaration of removing. And it’s the language of any individual who believes he has the authority to resolve who will get to remain, who should disappear, and whose presence contaminates the social order. Like father, like son.”
“Your phrases landed on high of centuries of Black kids being instructed they don’t belong in white colleges, neighborhoods, playgrounds, swimming pools, church buildings, white juries, white imaginations, and white definitions of innocence,” Patton continues. “They landed on high of each Black boy this nation has changed into a menace earlier than he ever had an opportunity to be a baby.”
Austin Metcalf’s Household Hit With Demise Threats As Karmelo Anthony Supporters Face Violence Allegations
She claimed that his son was not the one sufferer on this case and that Anthony’ household was additionally grieving.
Jeff Metcalf stands together with his son Austin Metcalf, a junior at Memorial Excessive College in Frisco, who was stabbed within the chest at a monitor meet, allegedly by 17-year-old Karmelo Anthony from Frisco Centennial Excessive College.
“Austin is useless. Your loved ones is devastated,” Patton wrote. “That issues. Karmelo Anthony is alive however caged inside a racial creativeness that had already convicted him. And that issues, too. Two households are shattered. And a complete nation is utilizing the tragedy to rehearse the identical previous script about Black guilt and white innocence.”
In an announcement to Fox Information Digital, Patton defended her opinion piece as a “critique of racial energy” and mentioned that she was not, “blaming a useless youngster, attacking a grieving father, excusing violence, and rejecting the authorized system.”
“My argument is easy: Black kids are kids,” Patton mentioned. “They don’t turn into monsters as a result of white America wants one, and their humanity is just not up for debate as a result of a verdict has been rendered.”
“Now, run alongside and feed your propaganda machine,” she added, declining to reply a number of of Fox Information Digital’s questions. “I am certain it is hungry for one more Black girl’s phrases to mutilate. That’s my assertion.”
Fox Information Digital reached out to Howard College and Metcalf’s household for remark.
Click on Right here To Obtain The Fox Information App
Patton’s Substack piece is the most recent in a rising refrain of voices arguing that the homicide case is rooted in race.
Rep. Jasmine Crockett, D-Texas, questioned on her podcast whether or not Karmelo Anthony’s race performed a job in his conviction. Crockett requested whether or not Anthony acquired a good trial, spreading a false declare that each one jurors had been white and that might have impacted their capability to be neutral.
“I’m not essentially satisfied — not that I may inform you the identify of 1 individual on this jury — that we had 12 neutral white folks out of Collin County sitting on a jury for this younger black man,” Crockett mentioned.
Crocket additionally steered black moms have confronted far larger agony on a day-to-day foundation than the sufferer’s household.
“Black ladies, particularly black ladies who’ve black male kids, dwell in worry and agony each single day,” she lamented. “A worry and agony that I promise you the Metcalfs most likely had by no means spend a day dwelling that method.”
Unique article supply: ‘You failed your son first’: Howard prof blames father’s values after Karmelo Anthony murdered his son