An Oklahoma teenager accused of sexually assaulting and strangling two highschool women noticed his legal case dismissed after finishing a youthful offender rehabilitation plan, all with out serving a jail sentence, court docket data present.
Jesse Mack Butler was 17 when he was charged as an grownup in Payne County in March 2025 with 10 felony counts tied to alleged assaults on two women he had dated.
The fees included two counts of tried first-degree rape, three counts of rape by instrumentation, sexual battery, forcible oral sodomy, two counts of home assault and battery by strangulation and one depend of home assault and battery.
Prosecutors later added an eleventh depend alleging that Butler violated a protecting order.
Newly Launched Video Exhibits Cops Cuffing Teen Linked To Violent Intercourse Assault Scandal That Has Households Fuming
Observe Us On X
Learn On The Fox Information App
Butler’s attorneys requested that he be licensed as a youthful offender or, alternatively, handled as a juvenile. The court docket denied the juvenile request however authorized youthful offender standing after prosecutors and the protection reached an settlement.
On Aug. 25, 2025, Butler pleaded no contest to all 11 counts. The choose discovered that he entered the pleas knowingly and voluntarily and that there was a factual foundation for them, based on the court docket docket reviewed by Fox Information Digital.
The court docket pronounced sentences of as much as 10 years on a number of counts however positioned Butler below the supervision of the Oklahoma Workplace of Juvenile Affairs as a substitute of sending him to jail.
California Mother Rips Newsom-backed ‘Diversion Program’ That Seems To Profit Her Son’s Killer
The sentence hung over him whereas he accomplished a court-approved rehabilitation plan. Evaluation listening to data from December 2025 and April 2026 stated Butler remained in compliance along with his rehabilitation plan.
At his remaining overview listening to on Aug. 3, prosecutors introduced they might not search to switch him into the custody or supervision of the Oklahoma Division of Corrections.
The court docket’s jurisdiction expired when Butler turned 19 at midnight on Aug. 4, inflicting the case to be dismissed by operation of legislation.
Observe The Fox True Crime Workforce On X
The ultimate listening to turned contentious when protection legal professional Derek Probability instructed Butler was harmless and was victimized by the case, based on newly elected Payne and Logan County District Legal professional Jeremiah Gregory.
Get Breaking Information By E-mail
“At present’s listening to included disingenuous assertions from the protection concerning the defendant’s innocence, that he was the sufferer on this matter and that the sufferer’s assertions had been false and had no bearing. The protection portrayed that by some means the perpetrator suffered greater than these victims. What was stated was insincere, untruthful and an affront to those victims and what they’ve endured,” Gregory stated in an announcement.
“Nothing has made my blood boil extra.”
Officers transfer in to arrest Jesse Butler as his mom seems on.
Click on Right here For Extra U.s. Information
Gregory stated Oklahoma can not prosecute Butler once more due to constitutional protections towards double jeopardy.
Get Breaking Information Alerts
He introduced that his workplace would as a substitute refer the matter to the suitable federal company for prosecutorial overview.
Ship Us A Tip
“I can not undo what has already been finished,” Gregory stated, “however I can — and can — proceed to face as a robust voice for all victims of violent crime.”
Like What You are Studying? Click on Right here For Extra
Bought A Tip?
No federal fees have been introduced.
Click on Right here To Obtain The Fox Information App
Fox Information Digital reached out to the Payne and Logan County District Legal professional’s Workplace, the Oklahoma Workplace of Juvenile Affairs, Butler’s legal professional and different attorneys linked to the case for added remark.
Authentic article supply: Oklahoma teen accused of raping two women walks free; DA furiously calls in feds: ‘Made my blood boil’