Sam’s
238 Courtroom St., nr. Baltic St., Cobble Hill
Georgia Fulton, entrance left, with a crew of neighborhood prospects contained in the new-old Sam’s.
Photograph: Scott Semler
Through the years, the near-century-old Sam’s was all the time closed in August. Louis Migliaccio, the proprietor, decamped to Italy for the month, depriving his regulars of pizza and parms till he returned and reopened nicely after Labor Day. The restaurant’s new proprietor, Georgia Fulton, inadvertently honored that custom this yr when she pushed a deliberate mid-summer reopening to September 10. Fulton wasn’t vacationing, nonetheless; a movie crew took up residence within the house.
Movie shoots had been additionally a frequent incidence on the previous Sam’s, which regarded loads like the brand new Sam’s, the most important additions to the décor being bar stools, bench seating close to the doorway for ready diners, and a partition that divides the bar from the eating space. Devoted clientele will acknowledge a lot of the menu, too. Holdovers embrace a celery-and-olives appetizer, baked clams, sides of spaghetti or ziti to go together with the veal parms and — in fact — the pizza that has anchored the menu for so long as anybody remembers. Not that re-creating the unique dishes was straightforward: Migliaccio’s recipes, after they existed in any respect, had been written in a kind of non-public shorthand. “There was no recipe guide,” says Sam’s chef guide, Andrew Halitski. As an alternative, “Lou confirmed me the particular espresso cups and dishes he’d use to do the measurements.” The well-known pizza oven introduced its personal set of considerations: It has no thermostat and operates on two gasoline pipes. “These ovens simply must be babied a bit bit,” Halitski says.
There are some additions to the menu — orecchiette with broccoli rabe and sausage, Caesar salad, rigatoni alla vodka, and a pork chop Milanese — nevertheless it’s fully potential no one will acknowledge them as such. “We’ve finessed it so it’s fairly near the unique,” says Fulton. The precise menus had been designed by Could Redding, who up to now has collaborated on her sister Ann’s eating places, together with Thai Diner: “We labored from a bunch of previous menus and archival materials going again nearly to the restaurant’s opening,” Redding says. “The aim was actually to protect the unique character whereas updating it a bit.”
One other replace: drinks. Sam’s all the time had a protracted cocktail checklist, nevertheless it was principally for present. Now, it’s introduced in earnest. “That is red-sauce, Italian American. It’s not an Italian restaurant,” says Rene Hidalgo, who’s answerable for the bar. “We’re not attempting to create one thing wholly new as a result of you’ll be able to’t try this with any such delicacies. That’s the lens we’re wanting by way of: How far-off from this factor can we get the place it nonetheless continues to be this factor?” Classics — a Cuba Libre, a Singapore Sling, a Rob Roy with each Cutty Sark and Laphroaig within the combine — will sit alongside trendy innovations like a home spritz with rhubarb amaro and a “shakerato” riff on the all of the sudden very-popular Spaghett, fabricated from shaken-up Aperol topped with Miller Excessive Life.
The glassware for these drinks isn’t altering, although. Nor are the plates. The old style green-trimmed dishes Migliaccio had are nonetheless in use, and salads can be served in picket bowls with steel tongs. The identical aim, Fulton says, has been pushed each determination: “Getting it as shut as potential to the unique — however higher.”
You’ll already acknowledge the signal.
Photograph: Scott Semler
Thanks for subscribing and supporting our journalism.
When you choose to learn in print, you too can discover this text within the September 7, 2026, difficulty of
New York Journal.
Need extra tales like this one? Subscribe now
to help our journalism and get limitless entry to our protection.
When you choose to learn in print, you too can discover this text within the September 7, 2026, difficulty of
New York Journal.
EAT LIKE THE EXPERTS.
Join the Grub Road publication.
Vox Media, LLC Phrases and Privateness Discover
See All