Anthony Falco will open his new spot in Williamsburg.
Illustration: Berta Vallo
A decade in the past, Anthony Falco deserted his life because the “pizza czar.” It was the made-up title he was given in his position as pizzaiolo and director of pizza operations at Roberta’s in Bushwick (and the title of his latter cookbook). Falco was able to department out on his personal and started to actively scout restaurant areas. As a substitute, he grew to become a world pizzeria guide and suggested “dozens and dozens” of institutions in additional than 23 international locations. He’s helped open locations within the Dominican Republic, Kuwait, Taipei, and Mongolia (amongst many others) and have become a associate in a single, Bráz Elettrica, in Brazil. This fall, he’s discovering his approach again house and can open the primary pizzeria of his personal, Pizzeria the Pantheon Bar, in Williamsburg. “Ten years on the street acquired a bit of previous,” he says. “I need to be making pizza with my household.”
Falco was born in Austin, Texas, and moved to New York in 2007. He labored at a dive bar, then started making dough at Roberta’s when it opened in 2008. The pies weren’t fairly Neapolitan in type and identified for his or her then-unusual topping mixtures from the bounce: The Bee Sting was spicy soppressata and scorching honey; the Speckenwolf, a speck and mushroom pizza impressed by Alsatian tarte flambée; and Falco’s namesake, the Millennium Falco, featured crumbles of spicy pork sausage and thin-sliced crimson onion.
He took that very same aptitude world wide, however, with a spouse and two younger children, says, “I need to be making pizza with my household.” The identical is true for his enterprise associate, Mateo Vivas, an trade vet Falco met ten years in the past. It was Vivas who finally discovered the location for the brand new pizzeria whereas eating at I Cavallini in Williamsburg. Vivas identified that the previous June’s Home of Crystals was sitting vacant and appeared to examine lots of the containers the pair had been on the lookout for: a clear basement, an affordable measurement, and a yard (this one trestle’d with native grapes; Falco hopes the vines will sometime kind into some form of pergola, however they really feel pseudo-Italian within the meantime).
The inside house was fully empty earlier than building acquired underway. Falco and Vivas introduced in a Swedish-style darkish timber bar from the Nineteen Fifties, which they present in a tortilla manufacturing unit in Bushwick. That is the place they’ll serve an Italian-leaning wine choice; Vivas additionally desires to make smoked-tomato negronis and guanciale-washed martinis, provided alongside a choice of the perfect glowing waters together with Vichy Catalan’s salty Spanish bubbles and Ferrarelle’s 1.5-liter bottles from Campania.
Terrazzo flooring result in a nook within the again proper the place they’ll nestle in a three-deck Moretti Forni electrical oven. Falco helped set up these sorts of ovens in different pizzerias at different undertaking and stays a fan: “It has very nice mushy warmth that means that you can do what you need.”
The title is impressed by Rome’s Pantheon — Queen Margherita of Savoy, the one which the Margherita pizza is known as after, is buried there, in any case — however it’s a extra direct reference to Alejandro Jodorowsky’s 1973 surrealist movie, The Holy Mountain, which follows a gaggle of individuals trying to find enlightenment; they’re distracted in a single scene once they come throughout the Pantheon Bar, which presents all worldly delights. This Pantheon Bar may, given Falco’s travels, feasibly provide all worldly kinds of pizza.
Whereas in Istanbul throughout considered one of his consulting gigs, Falco made pie with smoked rib eye seasoned with paprika and sumac that he completed with pomegranate molasses. (“It virtually ate like a BBQ pizza — acquainted to them, acquainted to me,” Falco remembers.) He’s made Turkish lahmacun, too, skinny and crispy, with minced meat and spices. And Vivas’s Argentine heritage would possibly immediate the duo to make the famed fugazza, double-crust cheese-stuffed pizza with a pile of cooked onions on high. (They’re toying with serving fainá on the facet — chickpea fritters just like the Sicilian panelle, which Argentines placed on high of their slices — as effectively.) However Falco says home components — Caputo Brothers Creamery mozzarella from Pennsylvania, Cairnspring Mills flour from the Pacific Northwest — would be the basis of his pies and possibly extra, like focaccia sandwiches with mortadella, or muffulettas. “I’ve finished so many kinds of pizza,” says Falco, “so I’m giving myself some choices right here. However on the finish of the day, we’re in New York.”
His plan for now’s to open just one: “We’re not trying to optimize and scale — it’s a neighborhood restaurant.” Additionally it is, he hopes, a spot that strikes at a slower tempo than lots of the nouveau slice joints that draw nearly all of the town’s pizza lovers lately. “I discover sit-down pizzerias inspiring,” Falco says. “Patsy’s, then Grimaldi’s, then Juliana’s, John’s of Bleecker — New York has develop into identified for the slice for positive, however it began with easy sit-down pizzerias.”
Thanks for subscribing and supporting our journalism.
When you want to learn in print, it’s also possible to discover this text within the October 5, 2026, challenge of
New York Journal.
Need extra tales like this one? Subscribe now
to assist our journalism and get limitless entry to our protection.
When you want to learn in print, it’s also possible to discover this text within the October 5, 2026, challenge of
New York Journal.
EAT LIKE THE EXPERTS.
Join the Grub Road publication.
Vox Media, LLC Phrases and Privateness Discover
See All