Kevin Del Aguila, David Patrick Kelly, and Ahmad Simmons in The Fantasticks, on the Hayes.
Picture: Joan Marcus
Attempt to bear in mind the primary time you skilled The Fantasticks. Even when you haven’t, you should still know its opening track, so completely different from the lollapaloozas that begin most up to date musicals — a easy, sweetly melancholy ballad earnestly asking the viewers to droop not a lot our disbelief as our sophistication. It has the uncommon high quality of sounding like a track that was someway occurred upon somewhat than written, and it’s not the one tune within the present — nonetheless, at 42 years Off Broadway, the file holder for longest-running musical wherever ever — to evoke that feeling. Tom Jones (e book and lyrics) and Harvey Schmidt (music) adopted The Fantasticks with a handful of Broadway productions, however time hasn’t essentially swept I Do! I Do! or Philemon together with it. In the meantime, each regional, group, and highschool theater within the nation has in some unspecified time in the future hung up a cardboard moon for the younger lovers Matt and Luisa to swoon beneath.
Now, although, in Christopher Gattelli’s charming Broadway revival, it’s Luisa no extra. The Fantasticks — a lilting comedian allegory of youth, love, and eventual maturation — has all the time advised the story of two neighboring children who fall for one another by a backyard wall constructed by their feuding dad and mom. These dad and mom, really buddies using reverse psychology to convey their youngsters collectively, are normally fathers, however right here they develop into a pair of completely successful mothers, as prepared with a vaudevillian softshoe as with clippers or watering can. And this time, each dad and mom have sons: Luisa has develop into Lewis.
The gender swap is, in fact, the massive hook of the manufacturing, and maybe it should really feel large to some. (It’s been making its method towards New York for years now, over the course of a number of completely different productions and a remodeling of the unique e book by Jones himself, 92 when he started the revision; he died in 2023.) Personally, I felt a bit like I think about I’ll if my baby ever tells me they’re homosexual: Oh candy one, in fact. The Fantasticks has such a pure, comfortable coronary heart — and takes place at such a fairy-tale take away from any particularly grounded social context — that nearly nothing else about it must be tweaked to accommodate the casting change. Some pronouns, in fact, and a few lyrics: Lewis now sings about longing to “go to city in a golden crown” as a substitute of a golden robe. (Too dangerous. Let Lewis put on no matter he desires!) However the character continues to be a fluttering, rhapsodizing romantic, with eyes full of a complete galaxy of stars. He nonetheless introduces himself by telling us conspiratorially, “The moon turns pink on my birthday yearly and it all the time will till any person saves me and takes me again to my palace!”
In Gattelli’s fingers, the manufacturing itself seems like a shiny however honest tribute by means of variation on a theme. Our first glimpse of the Hayes stage reveals solely the modest parts which have all the time been staples of The Fantasticks — a wood stage crate, a ghost mild, a easy curtain, a piano, and a harp. However because the overture performs, the area progressively transforms, its metamorphosis overseen by the Mute (the balletic and facially elastic Ahmad Simmons), a mime who exists on the fringes of the play’s story, pulling the ropes and throwing the confetti that flip all of it into theater. Away rolls the black crate painted with the phrases “Sullivan Avenue Playhouse” — the tiny Greenwich Village theater that housed The Fantasticks’ historic Off Broadway run. Now, on a freshly revealed stage with a again wall of whitewashed bricks, right here comes a brand new crate stamped “Hayes Theater.” The crate is white, identical to the wall, identical to the raised thrust stage ground dotted with footlights, and the ladder the Mute climbs when he must develop into a wall or cling up a crescent moon. Scott Pask’s set turns into a type of benevolent ghost — the translucent shadow of so many Fantastickses previous, able to saturate with coloration for these new younger lovers or to bleach like whalebone of their moments of disillusionment and despair.
As a result of disenchantment is half of what The Fantasticks is about. It preceded Into the Woods by 26 years, however in its personal humble method it has the identical construction: The primary act is a fairy story; the second act is the morning after. In Act One, we meet Matt (Maxim Chlumecky) and Lewis (Nathan Levy) within the morning glow of their love. “You’re Polaris or the within of a leaf,” sighs Matt, earlier than the pair soar previous the clumsiness of phrases: “Love, you’re love! / Higher far than a metaphor / Can ever, ever be.” Lewis and Matt assume they’re forbidden one another, which in fact makes their intrigue all of the spicier. Within the meantime, their sly mamas are busy of their gardens and smiling to themselves over their boys’ summer time romance. As Bessie Mae Bellomy, mom to Lewis, and Mildred Hucklebee, mom to Matt, Ruthie Ann Miles and Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer are at the least 65 % of what makes this revival as pretty as it’s. (A major chunk of the remainder goes to David Patrick Kelly and Kevin Del Aguila, masterful of their buffoonery as a pair of dauntless, dusty outdated actors — however extra on them quickly.) Kritzer and Miles have simply as a lot chemistry as their boys, maybe much more, and so they deploy it meticulously and brilliantly. Their renditions of “By no means Say No” and “Plant a Radish,” the musical’s two very humorous songs in regards to the impenetrable mysteries of parenting, are like attending to witness a dream model of MCC’s annual Miscast gala. With the latter of the 2 songs, the manufacturing’s workforce goes even additional, attaining a mild little revelation by slowing down the start and letting Miles — so gifted with each comedy and pathos — begin out mournfully, solely warming up over time to the track’s eventual bounce and swagger.
That is the type of adjustment that provides extra really distinctive taste to this Fantasticks than the Luisa-Lewis swap. Relating to that swap, it’s really every part in regards to the present that has remained the identical that offers us alternatives to cock our heads and rethink. Matt, as the marginally older of the boys — the one who’s comically satisfied that he’s “grown-up, secure, keen to evolve” — has all the time dreamed of doing the saving whereas Luisa, now Lewis, desires of being saved. Hold the present hetero and such a building goes to begin to grate. Now, there’s one thing releasing in watching a younger man dream of getting “kissed upon the eyes” and carried off by “a braggadocio bandit.” The regendering permits for somewhat breath, somewhat leisure, even perhaps a drop of radical honesty: I imply, who doesn’t wish to get carried off by a scorching bandit generally?
Just like the Mute, that bandit is the musical’s different character who glides forwards and backwards throughout the brink of the stage, each sharing the characters’ world and serving as its narrator. He’s El Gallo (“Gai-yoh!” he fastidiously-yet-sexily corrects Kritzer’s Mildred), and right here Zane Phillips performs him in low-key Castilian daddy mode, black and pink clubbing boots paired with sheer black short-sleeved shirt in Linda Cho’s twist on the character’s basic Zorro apparel. No marvel Lewis is distracted and Matt’s feathers are ruffled: These biceps! For probably the most half, I discovered Phillips’s wry understatement interesting, although there have been moments the place I puzzled why he and Gattelli didn’t take the half additional — urgent a bit extra on the locations the place the character himself implies his personal relationship with all that’s darkish and harmful. To be truthful to this manufacturing, although, these moments have all the time been The Fantasticks’ weakest. The present is aware of it has to do one thing in its second act to represent the rocky inner progress of its younger heroes — as El Gallo says, “With no harm the center is hole.” Matt will get the driving “I Can See It,” wherein Jones and Schmidt do their greatest Bernstein and Sondheim impression, however Lewis is saddled with “Spherical and Spherical,” a clunky duet with El Gallo that tries to do an excessive amount of and, weirdly, finally ends up peddling a misleading type of conservatism: The world will solely bang you up, greatest to search out your coronary heart’s want in your personal yard. Aesthetically, it’s additionally the one time within the play — and this stays the case even in Gattelli’s zhuzhed-up model — the place the authors’ dedication to easy, out-of-the-trunk theater magic doesn’t fairly reduce it, even regardless of the participation of these two priceless gems, the bumbling thespians performed by Kelly and Del Aguila.
What a delight they’re, although — Kelly along with his shuffling Shakespearean posturing and Del Aguila’s cockeyed dedication to his clown’s career-long speciality. (Dying, in fact. “Folks used to cry out: ‘Die once more, Mortimer! Die once more!’” he reminisces, then provides sagely: “However in fact I by no means did.”) Although the arrival on Broadway of a “Gaytasticks” is, by sure lenses, a loads large deal, Gattelli’s fancified however in the end devoted rendition additionally reveals that what’s shaky in regards to the present is apt to remain shaky, whereas what’s stunning about it should all the time be stunning. Leaving its dreamy coziness behind, I discovered myself considering of a buddy, a trans artist, who wrote an essay in 2011 reflecting on makes an attempt by the homosexual group in California to overturn Proposition 8. Right here have been all these good queer {couples} going to courtroom to exhibit that they have been identical to straight individuals: They wished marriages the identical method they wished houses with a canine and a garden and one and a half baths. I bear in mind my buddy musing over this delicate cognitive dissonance — queerness may acquire a mainstream place for itself so long as it was formed like straightness, however what about different shapes totally? To not overburden a musical of true and lasting sweetness with rocks too heavy for its pockets — I’m solely questioning. After the pleasures of this Fantasticks, new in some methods but nonetheless, actually, totally its outdated self, what else may we, like Lewis unchastened, dare to think about?
The Fantasticks is on the Hayes Theater.
Join the Vulture Day by day
An leisure e-newsletter for the pop-culture obsessed.
Vox Media, LLC Phrases and Privateness Discover


