Cooper and Goodyear have been making tires in America for over a century now. Cooper Tire can hint its roots again to the 1910s, whereas Goodyear has been round for even longer: founder F.A. “Frank” Seiberling first established the model in 1898. That is not fairly early sufficient to make it the oldest tire model nonetheless working, but it surely’s nonetheless fairly early all the identical.
The 2 tire manufacturers share greater than only a made-in-America heritage and histories that stretch again greater than 100 years, although. Goodyear bought Cooper Tires in 2021, uniting these stalwarts of the American tire manufacturing trade underneath one roof. However whereas the 2 corporations share possession, Goodyear has a transparent benefit in tire high quality — at the least, based on Shopper Stories’ testing.
Goodyear positioned within the high 10 of Shopper Stories’ finest tires of 2025, alongside different distinguished names comparable to Nokian Tyres, Hankook, and Kumho. Conversely, Cooper Tires did not even make it into the 18 finest manufacturers, rating decrease in CR’s estimation than manufacturers comparable to Nitto and budget-oriented GT Radial.
Learn extra: 21 Main Tire Manufacturers Of 2025 Ranked
How Goodyear and Cooper Tires’ merchandise carried out
Goodyear tires on show at a tire store – Karolis Kavolelis/Shutterstock
Goodyear could have positioned nicely above Cooper Tires on CR’s checklist, however neither model seems to be to be essentially the most compelling selection for these trying to change their automobile tires. Shopper Stories’ best-performing tires of 2025, for instance, largely come from Michelin, with Continental and Nokian merchandise additionally within the combine for extra particular use-cases.
That mentioned, it is not like Goodyear does not make any good tires. These looking for a sporty summer time tire may conceivably think about a set of the model’s Eagle F1 Uneven 6 tires. CR charges these as having near-identical efficiency in elements comparable to dry braking, dealing with, and highway noise to different high-performance favorites comparable to Michelin’s Pilot Sport 4s and the Continental ExtremeContact Sport 02. The Goodyear Assurance ComfortDrive all-season SUV tire can also be a strong selection, incomes a CR Really helpful award for its sturdy general efficiency and nice low-noise working, though it is nonetheless nicely behind choices from Michelin and Vredestein.
In distinction, the one Cooper Tires providing Shopper Stories reviewed, the Cooper ProControl all-season tires, had been fairly mediocre general. Whereas they had been first rate within the dry, sub-par braking efficiency in moist and icy climate arguably meant that it did not reside as much as its all-season branding. Whereas it is not the worst all-season tire in CR’s database, you are seemingly higher off spending further to get a considerably higher product just like the Vredestein Quatrac Professional+.
Need the newest in tech and auto traits? Subscribe to our free e-newsletter for the newest headlines, knowledgeable guides, and how-to ideas, one e mail at a time. It’s also possible to add us as a most well-liked search supply on Google.
Learn the unique article on SlashGear.