George McNally.
Picture: Krista Schlueter/The Sunday Occasions Type Journal/Information Licensing
There are numerous alternative ways to interpret the identify of the upcoming Tribeca restaurant, Fake. It might discuss with the important restaurant ability of making a make-believe area that evokes the romance of, say, Paris. It may be a play on its homonym, foe, a nod to the wrestle between generations, the outdated order difficult the brand new; or the wrestle between restaurant employees and demanding clients. However, as Fake’s proprietor, George McNally, says, it’s principally a matter of typographic aesthetics. “I like various things with Xs and Vs. Particularly issues with the completely different letters that seem in Roman numerals.” Just a few beats later, maybe unintentionally, McNally additionally lets slip that there may be a deeper that means: “Opening a restaurant for the primary time, I really feel like I’ve imposter syndrome.”
Although the venture shall be McNally’s formal introduction into the New York restaurant world, he isn’t unknown to New Yorkers. He seems, like the remainder of his household, in his father Keith’s 2025 memoir, I Remorse Nearly Every thing. (It was a then-13-year-old George who discovered his unconscious father after a suicide try. “I used to be so anxious about it popping out,” the youthful McNally says, “as a result of I knew it was fairly private.”) And Keith has been, he says, providing insights to him in each restaurant they’ve ever entered: “He’s at all times obtained one thing like whispers concerning the lighting or the sound.” Since transferring to New York from London in 2022, McNally has additionally been bartending on-and-off at his father’s flagship, Balthazar. “Now I’m doing like one or two shifts each few weeks,” he says. In dialog, he’s uncommonly shy (“I are inclined to mumble,” he mumbles), however behind the bar he comes alive. “I similar to the stage,” he says. “I like entertaining folks.” It’s also behind the bar that he’s discovered to maintain any ego in examine: “You’ll be able to’t ever suppose that you simply’re the fucking finest,” he says. “You’re not a genius or something. Shake drinks. Do it nicely. Study the historical past of it and know the bottom guidelines.”
McNally received’t be behind the bar at Fake, however he’s behind all the things else. He’s younger, after all, and there’s some kind of unstudied innocence about him. His tattoos learn candy issues, like “be good” on his left hand. On prime of the same old struggles of opening a restaurant in New York — and at an age when most individuals are getting entry-level jobs — George should wrestle with doing so whereas stepping out from his father’s important shadow. “I’ve one thing to show,” he says, “I need to be like, ‘I can do it.’” (Whether or not his father would have even been amenable to a partnership will stay an open query.) He’s spent the final yr elevating $1.5 million from buyers (“I assumed it will be asking 4 folks for $500,000 every,” he says, “but it surely’s, like, consistently bothering folks”) and has been working hand-in-glove with Ian McPheely, who has additionally designed Pastis and Balthazar, on particulars like moldings and lighting fixtures. “They’re based mostly on those from Fortunate Strike,” McNally says, “which was at all times one in every of my favorites of my dad’s locations.”
The menu — stuffed with straight-ahead crowd-pleasers — gives further shades of his dad’s locations. The immediate is Mediterranean. McNally’s chef, Kristina Ramos, has completed stints at Auberge la Fenière outdoors of Marseille in addition to the Minetta Tavern in D.C. “I didn’t need to make a fussy, fancy menu,” she says. There’s a burger with a riff on sauce algérienne (mainly spiced ketchup and mayo), steak-frites, pan-seared halibut, and mussels in sauce meant to evoke bouillabaisse. It’s the work of both a trepidatious first-timer or a seasoned restaurateur who is aware of the actual magic is within the alchemy, within the dance between clients, within the accumulation of a genius loci who elevate the air. It’s ineffable and, to some extent, unplannable. “Actually good service, actually good meals, however far more social, far more ambiance and comfy,” McNally says, ticking off the weather which might be most vital for Fake. “In no way pretentious — it’s not going to be white-tablecloth.”
He’s aiming to open this summer time, however as of early June, the area continues to be a sea of drywall and uninstalled HVAC ducts leaning towards uninstalled mirrors. On today, McNally is eagerly awaiting the supply of some tiles, and he doesn’t appear nervous. “It’s all fabricated already — they simply want to put in it,” he says. “You must be comfy with it wanting like a complete mess. I imply, there’s a stage the place it shortly comes collectively.” Is that recommendation gleaned from his dad? Not precisely, in keeping with McNally. “My father may be very palms off with all the things. He’s probably not one to be like, ‘Let me aid you.’”
Thanks for subscribing and supporting our journalism.
Should you desire to learn in print, you too can discover this text within the June 15, 2026, challenge of
New York Journal.
Need extra tales like this one? Subscribe now
to help our journalism and get limitless entry to our protection.
Should you desire to learn in print, you too can discover this text within the June 15, 2026, challenge of
New York Journal.