Christie Brinkley (proper) celebrates son Jack Paris Brinkley-Prepare dinner’s thirtieth birthday with daughter Alexa Ray Joel (second from left) on the Surf Lodge in Montauk at 5 p.m. on a Saturday.
Photograph: Mark Peterson/Redux for New York Journal
It’s a matter of little or no controversy, on the far-eastern tip of this skinny island the place all the things has the wealthy potential for controversy, that nobody goes to the Hamptons for the eating places. Meals, perhaps — to browse among the many $16-a-pint berries at Spherical Swamp Farm or to collect one among Carissa Waechter’s tarts which can be as elaborately flowered as a bridesmaid’s bouquet — however there’s a cause the genius loci of East Hampton, its titled Contessa, is Barefoot and entertaining at dwelling. Good issues develop out right here. However eating places?
“The Hamptons, if you already know, you already know, that once you exit, it’s not likely in regards to the eating,” society inside designer and Springs resident Sasha Bikoff confirmed to me. “You exit since you desire a scene and also you desire a vibe and also you wish to inform folks, ‘Oh, I’ve made this reservation. I acquired into this place,’” she added. “Particularly on weekends, you go to those eating places and also you count on the unhealthy service. You count on your order to be incorrect.”
That’s exaggerating, if solely simply. The scene, divided between the stalwart perennials and the buzzy annuals, has its highlights, however regardless of the quietly acknowledged mediocrity of many of the institutions, getting a desk nearly wherever is a dependable nightmare. “It’s like an Olympic sport within the Hamptons,” stated Bobbi Brown, the cosmetics baroness whose present line, Jones Street, is known as for the Hamptons road. “Yearly, it’s increasingly more folks.” And youthful and youthful.
The Hamptons Concern
See All
We’re a good distance out from the ragged summer season redoubt of the ’50s, when Willem de Kooning and Franz Kline performed within the annual Artists & Writers softball recreation. The Institution varieties have been joined by the zoomers. “All of the Higher East Siders simply need the acquainted,” one Hamptons employee advised me. After per week or so of consuming round, I’ve to agree. If there’s an epitome of the scene, it’s acquired to be the East Hampton Grill, owned by the restaurant group that runs Hillstone, within the house the place legendary adman Jerry Della Femina as soon as tried to increase his Manhattan success to an East Hampton restaurant. Now, the Grill is the East Finish’s Polo Bar, right down to the framed American flag and the classic pommel horse, and it’s about pretty much as good because it will get out right here, sometimes excellent. I couldn’t argue with the “fork and knife” ribs I ordered simply earlier than Memorial Day, sticky candy and falling off the bone, even when a $68 (filet mignon) steak-frites was salty sufficient to be almost inedible. The season hadn’t began, and the Grill was nonetheless reliably fullish, a desk of gays and women celebrating a birthday with candles within the hot-fudge sundae and home martinis with Hendrick’s gin, St-Germain, and Sauvignon Blanc.
The Grill is among the uncommon institutions that appeals to locals and summer season locals alike. (It helps that it stays open year-round.) So many others pull from elsewhere. At Le Bilboquet in Sag Harbor, an extension of a Manhattan restaurant, shrimp cocktail was $35 for 5, with a harbor-side yacht view, washed down with a gobletful of spritz. (On a current go to, on reverse sides of 1 pier, the 174-foot super-yacht Kisses lolled subsequent to the 142-footer Incentive — a bit on the nostril!) The vibe was scruffier, although nonetheless with yacht views, at Sag Harbor Tavern within the outdated American Legion, the place the hardly adorned burger was pretty much as good as its counterpart in Crimson Hook. However we’re right here for the East Finish, not a style of the boroughs. For this, there are the lobster shacks and clam bars, offered you possibly can abdomen some vacationers. Most well-known is Lunch, the inspiration for the restaurant in Showtime’s The Affair (a truth it proudly declares), or the close by Clam Bar on Route 27. My private favourite is Bostwick’s, the place the car parking zone fills with Teslas and BMWs however the await a desk with plastic buzzer in hand democratizes all. The transfer is native flounder, fried as a fishstick, and off-menu fried calamari doused in Buffalo sauce.
There may be fixed turnover, and the sport stays zero-sum — there’s solely a lot industrial house within the tiny cities, and residents could be fast to protect their territory from boozy incursions. The ecosystem right here revolves across the short-term whims of the visiting courses. “It’s not a simple market, and it takes so much to maintain one thing open and hold folks employed,” Joey Wölffer of Wölffer Property Winery advised me. Prefer it or not, the Hamptons should bend to its carpetbaggers.
The stackedness of the scene continues to lure the courageous. The Palm Seaside hoteliers Sarah and Andrew Wetenhall bought the Hedges Inn in February and put in the outdated New York institution Swifty’s as its in-house restaurant, the place dinner could be served, wedding ceremony type, beneath tents en plein air and the ready record for a desk is already 400-people robust. Donna Lennard’s four-year-old il Buco al Mare in Amagansett, a protracted blond-wood ship of a spot (starboard view onto an alley), serves pastas, pizzas, and eye-wateringly costly plated tins of fish. Jean-Georges Vongerichten’s tenure at Topping Rose Home endures, and his son Cédric’s Wayan and Ma.dé are again this yr, popping up for his or her third summer season in a row.
There are native eminences, too. David Hart, the chef whose enterprise companions run Sen in Sag Harbor (by many accounts the East Finish’s finest sushi), has lately been on an growth path islandwide. Okay Pasa in Sag serves tacos, whereas Smokey Buns in East Hampton serves burgers. A “Wiborg” burger, named after the native seaside, has roasted pink peppers and “baconnaise” and is served with a heap of fries in an outside picnic part that’s actually an alley jutting off one other alley. Is that this destined to change into a summer season scene? Certain, it’s behind Newtown Lane, but it surely’s additionally, and maybe extra, in entrance of the shared car parking zone behind the Cease & Store. Nonetheless, the reply appears all however sure: “Sure.”
The dowager queen of the scene is now and ceaselessly Nick & Toni’s in East Hampton (he the late Jeff “Nick” Salaway; she Toni Ross, daughter of erstwhile Time Inc. chairman Steven Ross). The identical hospitality group runs pubby Rowdy Corridor and the side-by-side Mexican joints La Fondita and Coche Comedor, all of which supply various levels of fairly respectable meals, however Nick & Toni’s stands alone for its status-granting energy (I’ve identified individuals who set a lot of their social inventory in securing “their” desk there). Steven Spielberg and Billy Joel are followers. So was Nora Ephron, who as soon as proclaimed, “I don’t have time to get romantically concerned with one other restaurant. I’m married to Nick & Toni’s.” And so, after a current go to for well-cooked half-chicken and a crispy plate of lemon-spritzed zucchini fritti (on the menu because the place opened in 1988), am I. If the wheel isn’t being reinvented, at the very least it nonetheless spins.
The eating places that evolve have a tendency to take action out of necessity. For 30 years, Dave’s Grill (later Dave’s Gone Fishing) sat fortunately on the water in Montauk, reservable solely in individual or by ever-busy phone. First, it moved to the opposite facet of the lake, then gave up the restaurant solely, residing on as Dave’s at House, offering for the new-local group within the truest means doable: by catering. The actual standing consuming, in spite of everything is claimed and accomplished, is consuming at dwelling — a nicer dwelling than your individual, in the event you’re fortunate. “You’ll see Bermuda Celebration Leases vehicles 20 instances a day,” Joel Mesler, the artist and someday gallery proprietor who moved to East Hampton in 2016, advised me. A present of his work opens at Guild Corridor in East Hampton in August, and the celebration dinner beforehand is being held not at Nick & Toni’s or Bilboquet however at a collector’s home overlooking the ocean. “You simply deliver it in,” Bobbi Brown admitted. “It’s simply, truthfully, the nicest technique to be within the Hamptons.” In it however not of it, it might appear, which raises the query, Why right here, anyway? Absolutely there are many coasts and loads of fabulous digs that don’t require hours of site visitors on 27 East. Brown went down that path for a time. “We left for the Jersey shore,” she advised me from her automotive (on the best way out East). “They didn’t even have arugula, so we needed to come again.”
Thanks for subscribing and supporting our journalism.
If you happen to favor to learn in print, you can too discover this text within the June 23, 2025, problem of
New York Journal.
Need extra tales like this one? Subscribe now
to help our journalism and get limitless entry to our protection.
If you happen to favor to learn in print, you can too discover this text within the June 23, 2025, problem of
New York Journal.
EAT LIKE THE EXPERTS.
Join the Grub Road e-newsletter.
Vox Media, LLC Phrases and Privateness Discover